Fringe Box

Socialize

FacebookTwitterRSS

West Horsley Residents Object, But New Housing Plans Are Approved

Published on: 23 Oct, 2026
Updated on: 25 Oct, 2026

The housing site in West Horsley (Credit: Arktec Ltd)

By James Moules

local democracy reporting service

Four new houses have been approved to be built in the spacious garden of an existing  property in West Horsley, despite fierce opposition from residents.

More than 40 people wrote to Guildford Borough Council opposing plans to build the four new detached homes in the garden of Hornbeam at 174 The Street, West Horsley.

A carport would also be included alongside each home, which would have four bedrooms. This scheme was revised from previous proposals which had suggested two three-bedroom and three four-bedroom homes for the plot.

The plans were vociferously opposed by many residents, with some voicing concerns about over-development in their village while others argued it would harm the broader rural setting.

Speaking before the planning committee, resident Oliver Van-Hay said: “The presumption in favour of sustainable development is not a presumption in favour of any development.”

Others wrote to complain about the volume of development in the area more broadly in recent years.

“Consideration of existing owners in the area should be important; we moved into the area three years ago, semi-retired, and have had building works constantly happening around us,” one resident wrote.

“The noise, disruption, road closures and constant development in this area is totally unacceptable and causes us unnecessary stress and anxiety.”

However, planning officers recommended that the development be approved, arguing that it complies with national planning policy and would “not result in harm to the character of the area”.

“The proposal also respects the amenity of the adjacent neighbours and, subject to the recommended conditions, would not result in detrimental impacts on trees, highways, surface water flood risk, biodiversity or ecology,” the officers wrote.

While many councillors voiced sympathy for residents’ concerns, they broadly agreed there were few material planning grounds on which the development could be refused, and voted to approve the proposals.

Cllr Pat Oven

Cllr Patrick Oven (Guildford Greenbelt Group: Send & Lovelace) said: “I’ve considerable sympathy for people not just in West Horsley, but in East Horsley as well in view of the incredible amount of development that they’ve had.”

He said he would rather the development had featured smaller houses, saying: “Much as I would like to be able to vote against this, I’m afraid I cannot find any planning reason to do so.

“Looking at this objectively, even though I have considerable sympathy, I would like to refuse it, but I’m afraid I feel my hands are tied.”

He added: “I could just sit on my hands and abstain, but that would be the cowardly thing to do.”

 

Share This Post

Leave a Comment

Please see our comments policy. All comments are moderated and may take time to appear. Full names, or at least initial and surname, must be given.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *