Fringe Box



£350k Cost of GBC Investigation into Housing Revenue Account Overspend

Published on: 23 Nov, 2023
Updated on: 23 Nov, 2023

By Emily Coady-Stemp

local democracy reporter

Guildford’s cash-strapped borough council will spend up to £350,000 on an investigation into potential fraud in its housing department.

See also: Councillors Told of £16 million Contract Overspend in Closed Meeting

Guildford Borough Council confirmed police are working alongside an accredited anti-fraud investigation unit to look into the issue, which came to light in July.

Work has begun to look into issues including overspending on contracts and problems with contract management regarding spend, compliance and delivery.

While some costs will be met by the council’s housing department, such as the costs of interim and agency staff, other costs relating to the investigation and reviewing internal governance will be paid for out of the council’s day-to-day budget.

A report, to be discussed at a special meeting of the council’s corporate governance and standards committee on Wednesday (November 29), said allegations of potentially fraudulent activity had been raised, which may have caused financial loss to the council.

The report said: “In July 2023, an external investigation team was instructed to consider the allegations that there may have been some wrongdoing within the council in respect of the council’s relationship with one or more  contractors.

“An accredited anti-fraud investigation unit is working alongside the police in respect of this matter.”

Costs incurred to the council so far include an external investigation team from Reigate & Banstead Borough Council, forensic analysis costs, and legal advice.

These costs could reach between £50,000 to £100,000 “dependent upon the volume of legal advice sought”.

The remaining estimated £200,000-£250,000 would be spent on an internal governance review, including external experts, and “dedicated admin support”, according to meeting documents.

As well as pausing and reviewing some contractual works, the council will terminate some contractual arrangements.

The report said: “The priority in recent weeks has been to stop the continuation of any potential wrongdoing, whilst supporting the delivery of the service to the council’s tenants.”

Following initial work to look at the “contract failures, to stop any potential wrongdoing and overspending, and to stabilise the service”, the council will now look at the “governance failures” that have occurred.

This will include setting up a Strategic Project Board for housing that the external investigation team will report to at least every month.

Cllr Julia McShane

The council’s leader, Julia McShane (Lib Dem, Westborough), said Guildford would continue working with external authorities to deal with the matter “efficiently and thoroughly”.

Cllr McShane, who is also the lead councillor for housing, said: “I understand that this has been a concerning time for our tenants.

“I want to reassure our tenants that their welfare continues to be our absolute focus.

“Our officers are working in a robust and diligent manner to ensure that we follow a methodical process throughout this very serious and sensitive matter.”

Richard Bates, GBC’s interim finance chief

Richard Bates, the council’s interim finance chief, told a meeting of the corporate governance and standards committee on Thursday (November 16) that the number of jobs being looked into in the housing department was “immense”.

Speaking before the report for the November 29 meeting had been published, he said officers could not answer many questions relating to the housing department, because they did not want to interfere with the internal and external investigations.

Share This Post

Responses to £350k Cost of GBC Investigation into Housing Revenue Account Overspend

  1. Jules Cranwell Reply

    November 24, 2023 at 5:39 am

    Since Cllr. McShane was responsible for housing, and failed to notice this alleged major fraud going on, should she not do the decent thing and resign?

  2. Valerie Thompson Reply

    November 26, 2023 at 11:02 pm

    What a wicked waste of money. Those at fault should admit their guilt and resign, as should Cllr McShane – immediately. GBC cannot afford these failing councillors.There are many more important things to spend our money on!

  3. RWL Davies Reply

    November 28, 2023 at 12:38 pm

    Don’t expect councillors to admit to failures or anybody to be held accountable.

    Thereare always “cuts” and Covid as excuses in waiting.

    Would the fraud have been discovered sooner, or even avoided, if there’d been less “working” from home?

Leave a Comment

Please see our comments policy. All comments are moderated and may take time to appear.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *