Fringe Box

Socialize

FacebookTwitterRSS

Letter: Questions Should Be Asked Before a Mayor for Surrey Is Accepted

Published on: 16 Nov, 2026
Updated on: 16 Nov, 2026

From Bernard Quoroll

former local authority CEO

In response to: ‘A Lot of Detail’ Still to Come on a Strategic Mayor for Surrey

Our representatives would be very well advised to look before encouraging us all to leap and to share with us the answers to many questions, before trying to lead us lemming-like over a cliff.

Here are just a few.

  • What will be the estimated annual cost of a further tier of local government, how will that translate into higher council taxes and what powers will the new agency have to precept on taxpayers via two new unitary councils?
  • When funds are released to super mayors, would that be new money or simply at the expense of other financial commitments?
  • What specific new powers would a super mayor have, how would they compare with the powers granted to mayors in other ‘regions’ and would any of those powers be at the expense of the powers and functions of the two new unitary councils, either now or in the future?
  • What will the penalty be for failing to meet the expectations of the government enshrined in such deals and what discretion might super mayors and unitary councils have to plot a different direction in the future?
  • What ability will a super mayor have to impose his or her will on the two new unitary councils, if they are not in agreement with any specific proposal and what constraints will there be on the future actions of such individuals?
  • What constitutional safeguards would prevent any “deal” being undone in the future, to the ongoing detriment of local government?
  • Will local people be directly consulted and with enough detail to enable a considered judgement to be made before a commitment?

It has to be remembered that this government’s new-found enthusiasm for devolution has not been as a result of any national conversation about what devolution should actually mean. Each deal has been delivered privately and piecemeal.

In most cases, it started out as a bribe to encourage existing councils to cooperate with an imposed restructuring, without bothering to consult their own communities in advance.

We can be sure that no deal will be struck unless it fits a central government game plan. We can also be sure that without constitutional underpinnings, what is given today can just as easily be taken away tomorrow by the same or a future government. Without constitutional safeguards, this is just another chapter in a regional funding game of snakes and ladders.

Of course, the promise of additional funding is attractive to local politicians who want to be able to say they made a difference during their tenure in office. Like all politicians however, they seem to have difficulty seeing beyond the next election, leaving citizens and taxpayers to pick up the pieces.

We are all beginning to understand that when something seems too good to be true, it probably isn’t and that when someone presses us to act quickly it a clear sign that they don’t want us to read the small print.

The promise of extra funding is quite simply one written on water and one which I pray we will not all have cause to regret. Sadly, and based on my own experience in public service, I think I already know the answer to that one.

Share This Post

Leave a Comment

Please see our comments policy. All comments are moderated and may take time to appear. Full names, or at least initial and surname, must be given.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *