Fringe Box



Letter: I Proposed Changes To the Council’s Governance Arrangements

Published on: 18 Jun, 2015
Updated on: 18 Jun, 2015
Cllr Susan Parker.

Cllr Susan Parker.

From Susan Parker

Leader of the Guildford Greenbelt Group

In the wake of the Juneja case, at Tuesday’s [June 16] joint scrutiny committee meeting I made the following suggestion…

I propose a detailed structural review of internal governance arrangements. I believe this is necessary because:

a) the previous lead councillor for governance and planning has just received a suspended sentence for forgery and fraud. She had some considerable input into the governance of this council;

b) the council chose to appoint Dr Robin Hooper, in order to lead the review into Ms Juneja. Dr Hooper was advising Guildford Borough Council on its governance arrangements, apparently reporting in part to Ms Juneja. I believe that appointment commenced in December 2013, apparently at the same time as Dr Hooper was conducting the review into public complaints about Ms Juneja’s qualifications. Dr Hooper had previously done work on the constitution for this council.
This might lead members of the public to conclude that there was a conflict of interest – or that at least Dr Hooper knew Ms Juneja and other senior councillors well, and therefore could not be said to have been wholly independent.

c) the Bar Standards Board wrote to Guildford Borough Council to note that a crime had been committed and suggested they reconsider their review. However, the council referred the matter to Dr Hooper who justified his previous conclusions rather than reviewing the issue again.

d) I understand from the press that the judge at the Old Bailey noted that there has been a breach of the councillors’ code of conduct. This supersedes the Managing Director’s report which clears the council. It makes it clear that this is indeed a matter that Guildford Borough Council should consider.

e) perception among the community is that because of the seniority of the lead member, there was an attempt at a whitewash which was in fact inappropriate.

As a result, I propose that there is an independent review of all governance arrangements at Guildford Borough Council, involving a specialist in local government who has not previously done any work for the council and is unconnected with any members or officers.

Share This Post

Responses to Letter: I Proposed Changes To the Council’s Governance Arrangements

  1. Lisa Wright Reply

    June 18, 2015 at 11:40 am

    And what will be the response to Cllr Parker’s suggestion from Cllr Mansbridge?

  2. Adrian Atkinson Reply

    June 18, 2015 at 12:01 pm

    You can see it here at about 1hr 16mins 50secs

  3. Jules Cranwell Reply

    June 18, 2015 at 1:09 pm

    From the webcast, it is apparent that Cllr Mansbridge still maintains that anyone who disagrees with his administration are both “offensive” and “myopic”. This is hardly the language one would expect from one respected colleague to another, and really quite shameful.

  4. Adrian Atkinson Reply

    June 19, 2015 at 10:42 am

    In the same breath Cllr Mansbridge also started to throw stones as to who or what can be believed. In this instance his aim was at what one reads in the press.

    I wonder exactly which publication, article or reporter he was referring to? Perhaps he can be more specific?

  5. Martin Elliott Reply

    June 21, 2015 at 4:01 pm

    Since those of us who are concerned about many aspects of GBC going back over a year, cannot get even a polite, let alone sensible, response is it not time to escalate the complaints to the Department for Communities and Local Government? Disgruntled tax payers in other boroughs were forced to do so and got satisfactory actions.

Leave a Comment

Please see our comments policy. All comments are moderated and may take time to appear.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *